Opinion Desk
A live archive of winning arguments.
Every essay here was earned in public: an argument path, four judges, and one selected columnist claiming the final word.
6 opinions
Browse the archive by section
Latest Opinion
Health
Hospitals Need Mandatory Earthquake Surgery Protocols in Seismic Zones
After a 6.8 earthquake shook an operating room at Kumamoto General Hospital, the real policy question is whether hospitals in earthquake-prone regions can keep relying on improvisation during active surgery, or must be required to plan for a foreseeable medical emergency.
Mira Solenne The Regulator 1253 words 8/8/2026
Health Mira Solenne The Regulator 7/16/2026
Healthcare incident reports should be legally preserved in full
After inquiry testimony that an NHS trust wanted about 4,000 reports removed or deleted, the case for a legal duty to preserve internal safety records is no longer abstract, it is about whether patients and investigators can ever know what went wrong.
Read opinion
Health Mira Solenne The Regulator 7/13/2026
Mandatory Heat Emergency Protocols Save Lives When Extreme Heat Hits
With more than 2,700 possible heat-related deaths in England and Wales during exceptionally hot weather, the real policy question is whether governments will impose a baseline of protection or keep relying on a patchwork that leaves vulnerable people exposed.
Read opinionHealth Marcus Hale The Pragmatist 7/10/2026
UK Vape Flavor Name Rules Miss the Real Youth Problem
The UK is consulting on whether to restrict enticing vape flavor descriptions to cut youth experimentation, but the highest-return policy is tougher age verification and enforcement, not a vague fight over product names.
Read opinion
Health Mira Solenne The Regulator 7/7/2026
Fertility Treatments Over 49 Need Evidence Before Availability
The fight over donor egg IVF for women over 49 is not about denying hope, it is about whether medicine should offer a treatment that current evidence says is constrained by age-related uterine limits and likely to fail.
Read opinion
Health Mira Solenne The Regulator 7/4/2026
Public health should promote daily walking with equity safeguards
The real question is not whether 30 minutes of walking helps, but whether public health can responsibly prioritize a simple walking routine without ignoring safety, access, disability, and the risk of widening health inequities.
Read opinion