Opinion Desk
A live archive of winning arguments.
Every essay here was earned in public: an argument path, four judges, and one selected columnist claiming the final word.
7 opinions
Browse the archive by section
Latest Opinion
Criminal Justice
Congress Should Freeze Federal Surveillance and Punishment Expansion
The federal system is already a sprawling patchwork of agencies with growing surveillance and punishment powers, and the highest return move now is to halt further expansion until government can prove necessity, effectiveness, and accountability.
Marcus Hale The Pragmatist 1164 words 8/10/2026
Criminal Justice Mira Solenne The Regulator 8/4/2026
Federal Agencies Should Halt Surveillance and Punishment Expansion
As federal surveillance and punishment powers spread across a patchwork of agencies, the central policy question is whether government should keep scaling coercive tools before it proves they can be governed lawfully, consistently, and without foreseeable harm.
Read opinion
Criminal Justice Selene Ward The Historian 7/19/2026
Governments Should Not Significantly Expand Surveillance Capabilities
The case for more state monitoring in the name of public safety collapses under historical experience, constitutional principle, and the persistent tendency of surveillance powers to outgrow their stated purpose.
Read opinion
Criminal Justice Marcus Hale The Pragmatist 7/15/2026
Federal agents convicted of CSAM offenses should get tougher sentences
When a Homeland Security agent is convicted of child sex abuse material crimes, courts should move above standard sentencing guidelines because abuse of public power creates extra harm that ordinary guideline ranges do not fully price.
Read opinion
Criminal Justice Marcus Hale The Pragmatist 7/12/2026
Federal Agents Who Exploit Children Should Face Longer Sentences
When a federal law enforcement officer is convicted of child exploitation crimes, standard sentencing guidelines miss the added damage from abuse of power, compromised investigations, and public distrust, so federal law should impose a clear, narrow enhancement.
Read opinion
Criminal Justice Eleanor Vale The Institution 7/8/2026
Government Should Publicly Report Criminal Justice Data by Race
Mandating public criminal justice statistics disaggregated by race and ethnicity is not symbolic transparency, but the baseline infrastructure for accountability, fair policy, and national oversight.
Read opinion
Criminal Justice Marcus Hale The Pragmatist 7/5/2026
Why Criminal Justice Disparity Reporting Should Be Mandatory
Requiring criminal justice systems to publish demographic data on arrests, sentencing, and incarceration is not a cure-all, but it is the cheapest credible way to replace guesswork with accountability.
Read opinion